12 Best Chicken Pot Pie Makers for Easy Homemade Pies in 2027

The best chicken pot pie makers depend on whether you want oven-baked individual pies or a faster electric option. My best overall pick is the Aunt Shannon’s Kitchen White Ceramic Mini Pie Pans, which balance individual portions with traditional oven baking. For batch baking on a budget, Spare Essentials’ 60-pack aluminum tins stand out, while the Sunbeam Pie Magic is the electric choice for people who want an appliance made for pies. The main tradeoffs are reusable versus disposable pans, oven flexibility versus appliance convenience, and deep filling capacity versus compact portions. Read on for the full comparison, selection criteria, and advice on matching a maker to your kitchen.

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime

• Fast, free delivery on millions of items
• Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
• Member-only deals all year

Start your free Prime trial →Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.Hide

Key Takeaways

• Oven-baked ceramic pans lead this lineup for versatility: Aunt Shannon’s four 5.5-inch dishes are my overall pick, while LOVECASA offers six pans for cooks who want more portions per batch.
• Electric pie makers suit a narrower cooking style: Sunbeam, Aoruru, MasterChef, and FineMade trade the flexibility of oven-safe dishes for appliance-based preparation; FineMade’s included crust cutter adds a shaping aid.
• Disposable pans solve cleanup and sharing, not long-term reuse: Spare Essentials supplies 60 standard 5-inch tins, while Durable Packaging offers 12 deeper 5 3/4-inch pans for roomier fillings.
• Pan diameter changes the meal more than the set count suggests: ONEMORE‘s 6.8-inch dishes give more room for a larger serving than the 5- to 5.5-inch options, but take up more oven and storage space.
• Not every pie-shaped tool is designed for a traditional pot pie: The Jumbo empanada press is suited to sealed hand pies, while Suwimut‘s eight nonstick pans emphasize quantity and easy release in a compact size.

Our Top Best Chicken Pot Pie Makers Picks

Aunt Shannon’s Kitchen White Ceramic Mini Pie Pans, Set of 4, 5.5-Inch		Best Reusable Individual Pans	Material: Ceramic	Quantity: 4 pans	Diameter: 5.5 inches	VIEW LATEST PRICE	See Our Full Breakdown
Spare Essentials 5-Inch Disposable Aluminum Pie Tins, 60 Pack		Best for Batch Prep and Easy Cleanup	Material: Aluminum foil	Quantity: 60 pans	Diameter: 5 inches	VIEW LATEST PRICE	See Our Full Breakdown
Aoruru Electric Pie and Quiche Maker		Best for Quick Bite-Size Pies	Capacity: 4 bite-size pies or quiches	Wattage: 800 watts	Voltage: 110 volts	VIEW LATEST PRICE	See Our Full Breakdown
FineMade Electric Mini Pocket Pie Maker with Crust Cutter		Best for Pocket-Pie Prep	Capacity: Up to 3 pocket pies	Pocket pie size: 4.5 × 2.5 inches	Wattage: 750 watts	VIEW LATEST PRICE	See Our Full Breakdown
MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Baker		Best for Six-Pie Electric Batches	Capacity: 6 mini pies or quiches	Mini pie diameter: 2.75 inches	Coating: Nonstick	VIEW LATEST PRICE	See Our Full Breakdown
Jumbo 6.25-Inch Empanada Maker Press with Cutter and Sealer		Best for Hand-Folded Pot Pie Pockets	Brand: MATJAZ BIZJAK	Size: 6.25 inches	Material: BPA-free, food-grade plastic	VIEW LATEST PRICE	See Our Full Breakdown
Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker		Best for Quick Countertop Pot Pies	Brand: Sunbeam	Model: 4805	Wattage: 1000 watts	VIEW LATEST PRICE	See Our Full Breakdown
LOVECASA Ceramic Mini Pie Pans, Set of 6, 5.5-Inch, White		Best for Individual Portions and Small Kitchens	Brand: LOVECASA	Material: Porcelain	Quantity: 6	VIEW LATEST PRICE	See Our Full Breakdown
ONEMORE Set of 4 Ceramic Mini Pie Pans, 6.8-Inch		Best for Hearty Individual Pot Pies	Brand: ONEMORE	Material: Ceramic	Quantity: 4 pie pans	VIEW LATEST PRICE	See Our Full Breakdown
Durable Packaging 5 3/4-Inch Deep Aluminum Foil Pie Pans, Pack of 12		Best for Batch Prep and Easy Cleanup	Material: Tin	Quantity: 12 pans	Capacity: 14.6 fluid ounces	VIEW LATEST PRICE	See Our Full Breakdown
ONEMORE 6.8-Inch Ceramic Pie Pans, 16 oz, Set of 4		Best for Individual Pot Pies	Material: Ceramic	Quantity: 4 pans	Capacity: 16 ounces each	VIEW LATEST PRICE	See Our Full Breakdown
Suwimut 8-Pack 5-Inch Nonstick Mini Pie Pans		Best for Batch-Making Mini Pies	Material: Carbon steel	Quantity: 8 pans	Diameter: 5 inches	VIEW LATEST PRICE	See Our Full Breakdown

More Details on Our Top Picks

1. Aunt Shannon’s Kitchen White Ceramic Mini Pie Pans, Set of 4, 5.5-Inch

   

   Best Reusable Individual Pans

   View Latest Price

   For pot pies served as separate portions, these four ceramic pans offer more of a traditional baking setup than an electric pie maker. Each holds about 9 ounces, giving filling and crust room in a small, round dish; the fluted rim also gives the pastry edge a finished shape. Unlike the Spare Essentials disposable tins, these are meant to be washed and reused, and they stack for storage. The tradeoff is capacity: these are firmly individual-size pans, not a way to bake one generous family pie. They also require you to prepare and bake each pie in an oven, rather than offering the quick, batch-style cooking of the Aoruru Electric Pie and Quiche Maker. Choose them for reusable, oven-baked servings; skip them if you need larger portions or an appliance that cooks pies for you.

   Pros:

   • Four reusable ceramic pans suit individual servings.
   • Oven-safe construction supports traditional baking.
   • Dishwasher-safe care makes cleanup easier.
   • Stackable design and fluted rims combine practical storage with a decorative finish.

   Cons:

   • Capacity of about 9 ounces per pan is too small for generous portions.
   • Requires separate crust preparation and oven baking rather than cooking pies automatically.

   Best for: Home cooks who want reusable oven-safe dishes for serving individual chicken pot pies, quiches, or tarts.

   Not ideal for: Cooks making large, family-size pies or buyers who want an electric appliance to form and cook pies in batches.

   • Material:Ceramic
   • Quantity:4 pans
   • Diameter:5.5 inches
   • Height:1.5 inches
   • Capacity:8.96 ounces each
   • Shape:Round
   • Oven safe:Yes
   • Care:Dishwasher safe
   Our verdict

   “Choose these if you want reusable ceramic dishes for modest, oven-baked individual pot pies, not large pies or appliance-made pockets.”

   → See it on Amazon →

2. Spare Essentials 5-Inch Disposable Aluminum Pie Tins, 60 Pack

   

   Best for Batch Prep and Easy Cleanup

   View Latest Price

   When the priority is making many individual pot pies with minimal washing afterward, this 60-pack of disposable tins fills a different role from the reusable ceramic pans in this roundup. Their 5-inch size suits single portions, and oven- and freezer-safe construction gives batch cooks a way to assemble pies ahead and bake them later. They can also serve catering or group meals where returning dishes is inconvenient. The clear compromise is durability: these aluminum foil pans are less substantial than the ceramic pans from Aunt Shannon’s Kitchen, so they may be less reassuring to handle when filled. They are disposable and recyclable, not a long-term bakeware investment. Compared with the MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Baker, they take oven preparation rather than producing six small pies in an electric appliance, but offer far more pans for storing or serving separate portions.

   Pros:

   • Pack of 60 supports large batches and group serving.
   • Oven- and freezer-safe for make-ahead pie prep.
   • Disposable construction reduces cleanup and dish returns.
   • Stackable pans are practical for storage.

   Cons:

   • Foil construction is less durable than reusable ceramic bakeware.
   • At 5 inches, the pans are intended for individual pies rather than family-size portions.

   Best for: Meal preppers, hosts, and caterers who want many individual pies that can be assembled, frozen, and baked without collecting reusable dishes.

   Not ideal for: Buyers seeking sturdy, long-lasting bakeware or cooks who prefer an electric appliance that cooks pies in repeatable batches.

   • Material:Aluminum foil
   • Quantity:60 pans
   • Diameter:5 inches
   • Maximum temperature:425 °F
   • Oven use:Suitable
   • Freezer use:Suitable
   • Care:Disposable, recyclable, stackable
   Our verdict

   “Pick these for high-volume individual pot pie prep and easy cleanup, but choose ceramic pans if sturdiness and repeated use matter more.”

   → See it on Amazon →

3. Aoruru Electric Pie and Quiche Maker

   

   Best for Quick Bite-Size Pies

   View Latest Price

   The Aoruru is the pick here for cooks who want an appliance to make four bite-size pies or quiches at once, rather than baking individual dishes in an oven. Its 800-watt electric design cooks in a few minutes, and a nonstick surface helps with release and cleanup. That speed comes with a different kind of pot pie: bite-size servings are better suited to snacks or small tastes than the fuller portions possible in the Aunt Shannon’s Kitchen 5.5-inch pans. The Aoruru also has just one setting, so there is little control to tailor cooking beyond the appliance’s built-in approach. Compared with the FineMade Pocket Pie Maker, it makes one more pie at a time, but the FineMade offers a crust cutter and larger pocket-pie dimensions. Its plastic construction is another tradeoff against the ceramic and stainless-steel options.

   Pros:

   • Makes up to four bite-size pies or quiches at once.
   • Cooks in a few minutes, according to the product description.
   • Nonstick surface helps with release and cleanup.
   • Compact design is convenient to store.

   Cons:

   • Single setting offers limited control over cooking.
   • Bite-size capacity may be too small for a meal-sized pot pie.
   • Plastic construction may feel less substantial than metal or ceramic alternatives.

   Best for: Cooks who regularly want four quick, bite-size pies or quiches and prefer an electric countertop appliance to oven-baked dishes.

   Not ideal for: Anyone seeking full individual pot pie portions, multiple cooking settings, or a more substantial metal-bodied appliance.

   • Capacity:4 bite-size pies or quiches
   • Wattage:800 watts
   • Voltage:110 volts
   • Number of settings:1
   • Material:Plastic
   • Coating:Nonstick
   • Color:Black
   • Included components:Waffle plates
   Our verdict

   “Choose the Aoruru for fast batches of small pies, but opt for the FineMade or ceramic pans if you want larger individual servings.”

   → See it on Amazon →

4. FineMade Electric Mini Pocket Pie Maker with Crust Cutter

   

   Best for Pocket-Pie Prep

   View Latest Price

   The FineMade suits cooks who want formed pocket pies rather than open-faced pies baked in dishes. It makes up to three 4.5 × 2.5-inch pies per batch, and the included crust cutter helps create pieces sized for the appliance. That accessory gives it a prep advantage over the Aoruru Electric Pie and Quiche Maker, which makes four bite-size pies but does not list a cutter; the Aoruru, however, handles one more pie at a time. The FineMade’s nonstick surface supports easier release and cleanup, while its compact dimensions make storage manageable. This is still a small-batch option, and its pocket format differs from the deeper, round servings you can bake in Aunt Shannon’s Kitchen ceramic pans. It also needs a 120-volt outlet, so it is less suitable where that power supply is unavailable.

   Pros:

   • Makes up to three pocket pies per batch.
   • Included crust cutter helps prepare evenly sized pastry.
   • Nonstick coating helps with release and cleanup.
   • Compact footprint supports convenient storage.

   Cons:

   • Limited to three small pocket pies per batch.
   • Requires a 120-volt outlet.
   • Pocket-pie format is less suited to traditional round, dish-baked pot pies.

   Best for: Home cooks who want evenly sized crusts and compact, enclosed pocket pies for snacks or smaller individual servings.

   Not ideal for: Anyone who needs more than three pies per batch, wants round oven-baked pot pies, or lacks a 120-volt outlet.

   • Capacity:Up to 3 pocket pies
   • Pocket pie size:4.5 × 2.5 inches
   • Wattage:750 watts
   • Voltage:120 volts
   • Dimensions:9.5 × 9.5 × 3.8 inches
   • Material:Stainless steel
   • Coating:Nonstick
   • Included accessory:Crust cutter
   Our verdict

   “Choose the FineMade for compact pocket pies and easier crust prep, but select an oven-safe pan for traditional round pot pie portions.”

   → See it on Amazon →

5. MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Baker

   

   Best for Six-Pie Electric Batches

   View Latest Price

   Among the electric options here, the MasterChef makes six mini pies or quiches at once, so it is the strongest fit when serving several small portions matters more than making larger pocket pies. Its 2.75-inch wells produce notably smaller pies than the FineMade’s 4.5 × 2.5-inch pockets, a useful distinction for snacks or tasting portions but a real limit for a meal-sized chicken pot pie. The included dough-cutting circle helps portion pastry, and the recipe manual offers a starting point for preparation. A nonstick coating supports release and cleanup. Unlike the oven-safe ceramic pans from Aunt Shannon’s Kitchen, this electric baker handles a set batch in its own appliance rather than letting you choose a larger dish size. Product dimensions are listed inconsistently, which makes storage planning harder.

   Pros:

   • Makes six mini pies or quiches at once.
   • Nonstick coating supports easier release and cleanup.
   • Dough-cutting circle helps portion pastry.
   • Instruction manual includes recipes.

   Cons:

   • The 2.75-inch pies are too small for many meal-sized servings.
   • Listed product dimensions are inconsistent, complicating storage planning.
   • Fixed multi-well format offers less flexibility than separate oven-safe pans.

   Best for: Hosts and cooks who want to make several very small pies or quiches at once and value a pastry cutter and recipe guidance.

   Not ideal for: Buyers seeking meal-sized pot pies, adjustable batch sizes, or dependable dimension details for tight storage spaces.

   • Capacity:6 mini pies or quiches
   • Mini pie diameter:2.75 inches
   • Coating:Nonstick
   • Included accessory:Dough-cutting circle
   • Included documentation:Instruction manual with recipes
   • Item weight:4.29 pounds
   • Model number:MTF-MPB-740
   • Manufacturer:MasterChef
   Our verdict

   “Choose the MasterChef for batches of small pies and included prep guidance, but pick larger pans or the FineMade if portion size is your priority.”

   → See it on Amazon →

6. Jumbo 6.25-Inch Empanada Maker Press with Cutter and Sealer

   

   Best for Hand-Folded Pot Pie Pockets

   View Latest Price

   For cooks who want sealed, portable pot pie portions rather than a dish-baked pie, this manual press cuts dough, folds it around filling, and crimps the edge in one tool. Its deep filling pocket gives you room for a hearty center, while the reinforced metal hinge pin and sturdy handles are designed to handle repeated pressing. Compared with the Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker, it doesn’t bake the pastry for you or speed up cooking; you still shape each piece by hand and bake it separately. The payoff is flexibility across empanadas, dumplings, and turnovers, plus dishwasher-safe cleanup. Its single 6.25-inch size is the main limitation: it may be too large for snack-size pastries and isn’t suited to traditional round pot pies.

   Pros:

   • Integrated cutter and crimper combine two dough-preparation steps
   • Deep pocket accommodates generous filling
   • Reinforced metal hinge pin and sturdy handles support firm pressing
   • Dishwasher-safe, BPA-free food-grade plastic

   Cons:

   • Requires manual folding and pressing, then separate baking
   • One 6.25-inch size may not suit smaller portions
   • Makes sealed pastries rather than dish-style pot pies

   Best for: Cooks who want to make sealed, hand-held chicken pot pie pastries and also prepare empanadas or turnovers with the same tool

   Not ideal for: Anyone seeking an appliance that bakes pot pies or a set of different pastry sizes

   • Brand:MATJAZ BIZJAK
   • Size:6.25 inches
   • Material:BPA-free, food-grade plastic
   • Hinge:Reinforced metal pin
   • Features:Integrated dough cutter and crimping sealer
   • Pieces:1
   • Care:Dishwasher safe
   • Color:Black
   Our verdict

   “Choose this press for hand-formed, sealed pot pie pockets and skip it if you want an appliance to bake the pie for you.”

   → See it on Amazon →

7. Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker

   

   Best for Quick Countertop Pot Pies

   View Latest Price

   The Sunbeam Pie Magic suits cooks who want a dedicated countertop appliance for fast individual pies, including pot pies, without heating a full oven. It is listed as baking pies in 10 minutes or less, and the included pair of dough cutters helps prepare crusts for its pie-making format. Quiche, fruit pies, and pizza add flexibility beyond chicken pot pie. Compared with the LOVECASA Ceramic Mini Pie Pans, this appliance offers a quicker, more contained cooking routine, but the ceramic dishes give you greater freedom to choose your oven recipe and portion size. The tradeoff is a single setting and a fixed appliance format: cooks who want control over oven temperature, or who regularly bake several pies at once, may prefer separate pans. Its nonstick coating and compact footprint favor convenient everyday use.

   Pros:

   • Bakes pies in 10 minutes or less according to the product description
   • Can make pot pies, quiche, fruit pies, and pizza
   • Includes two dough cutters for shaping crusts
   • Compact design and nonstick coating support convenient use and cleanup

   Cons:

   • Single setting offers limited cooking control
   • Fixed appliance format limits flexibility compared with oven-safe pie pans
   • Small countertop pie format may not suit larger servings

   Best for: Busy cooks who want a compact appliance for quick individual pot pies and other small savory or sweet bakes

   Not ideal for: Bakers who need multiple portion sizes, oven-based recipe control, or capacity for several pies at once

   • Brand:Sunbeam
   • Model:4805
   • Wattage:1000 watts
   • Settings:1
   • Dimensions:9.61 x 10.59 x 5.12 inches
   • Weight:4 pounds
   • Included components:Two dough cutters
   • Special features:Nonstick coating, compact design, wraparound cord
   Our verdict

   “Pick the Sunbeam for quick countertop pot pies, but choose ceramic pans if you want more control over oven baking and serving size.”

   → See it on Amazon →

8. LOVECASA Ceramic Mini Pie Pans, Set of 6, 5.5-Inch, White

   

   Best for Individual Portions and Small Kitchens

   View Latest Price

   This six-piece set is a practical match for households that want individual pot pies and compact storage without committing to an electric pie maker. Each 5.5-inch dish holds 8 ounces, so portions are clearly smaller than the 16-ounce ONEMORE Set of 4 Ceramic Mini Pie Pans. That makes the LOVECASA dishes a better fit for lighter servings, side portions, or a meal with several accompaniments; choose ONEMORE for a heartier filling. The porcelain pans handle oven temperatures up to 500°F and are also listed as freezer-, microwave-, and dishwasher-safe, giving them broad utility for prep and leftovers. The compromise is capacity: 8 ounces may not satisfy diners expecting a full individual entrée, and these dishes rely on your oven and recipe rather than providing appliance-style speed.

   Pros:

   • Set of six supports several individual portions
   • Oven-safe up to 500°F
   • Freezer-, microwave-, and dishwasher-safe
   • Stackable design helps limit storage space

   Cons:

   • 8-ounce capacity may be small for a main-course pot pie
   • Requires an oven and does not speed baking like the Sunbeam Pie Magic
   • Fixed 5.5-inch size offers no larger-pan option in the set

   Best for: Households preparing smaller individual pot pies, lighter portions, or several different fillings while saving cabinet space

   Not ideal for: Cooks serving hearty single-dish meals who need a larger portion than an 8-ounce pan can hold

   • Brand:LOVECASA
   • Material:Porcelain
   • Quantity:6
   • Capacity:8 ounces each
   • Diameter:5.5 inches
   • Maximum oven temperature:500°F
   • Care:Dishwasher-, freezer-, microwave-, and oven-safe
   • Shape and color:Round, white
   Our verdict

   “Choose LOVECASA for compact, smaller individual servings; the 16-ounce ONEMORE pans suit more substantial pot pies.”

   → See it on Amazon →

9. ONEMORE Set of 4 Ceramic Mini Pie Pans, 6.8-Inch

   

   Best for Hearty Individual Pot Pies

   View Latest Price

   With 16-ounce capacity per dish, this set is the stronger ceramic choice for a full, filling individual chicken pot pie. Its 6.8-inch diameter and deep design give more room for chicken, vegetables, and sauce than the LOVECASA 5.5-inch Mini Pie Pans, whose 8-ounce capacity favors smaller portions. The ONEMORE set contains four pans rather than six, so it prioritizes generous servings over serving more people in one batch. Ceramic suits cooks who want to bake in their own oven, and the listed dishwasher- and freezer-safe care makes it useful for prep and cleanup. Its 450°F oven rating is lower than LOVECASA’s 500°F, and the pans still need oven time; they won’t match the Sunbeam’s appliance-based speed.

   Pros:

   • 16-ounce capacity accommodates heartier individual servings
   • Deep 6.8-inch design suits savory pies with generous filling
   • Set of four works well for a small household or dinner guests
   • Listed as dishwasher- and freezer-safe

   Cons:

   • Four-pan set serves fewer portions than the six-piece LOVECASA set
   • 450°F oven limit is lower than the LOVECASA pans’ 500°F rating
   • Requires oven baking rather than the quicker appliance format of the Sunbeam Pie Magic

   Best for: Cooks who want substantial individual pot pies for four people and prefer oven-baked ceramic dishes

   Not ideal for: Anyone who needs six or more smaller portions, a higher oven-temperature rating, or faster appliance cooking

   • Brand:ONEMORE
   • Material:Ceramic
   • Quantity:4 pie pans
   • Diameter:6.8 inches
   • Capacity:16 ounces
   • Maximum oven temperature:450°F
   • Care:Dishwasher- and freezer-safe
   • Color and shape:Creamy white, round
   Our verdict

   “Choose ONEMORE when generous 16-ounce portions matter more than having six smaller dishes or a higher oven-temperature limit.”

   → See it on Amazon →

10. Durable Packaging 5 3/4-Inch Deep Aluminum Foil Pie Pans, Pack of 12

    

    Best for Batch Prep and Easy Cleanup

    View Latest Price

    For batch cooking, freezing, or sharing individual pot pies, these 12 disposable foil pans avoid the return trip from table to sink. Each holds 14.6 fluid ounces, landing between the smaller 8-ounce LOVECASA Ceramic Mini Pie Pans and the 16-ounce ONEMORE dishes. That middle capacity works for many individual pot pies, though portion needs vary. The pans are listed for use up to 400°F, so check that limit against your recipe before baking; ceramic alternatives offer higher stated temperature limits and can be reused. These pans are specifically marked disposable and not intended for reuse, which is convenient when cleanup or transport matters but creates ongoing waste and less long-term use from each pan. Their small footprint also rules them out for full-size pies.

    Pros:

    • Pack of 12 provides pans for batch cooking or sharing
    • 14.6-fluid-ounce capacity suits individual pot pies
    • Disposable format avoids washing and simplifies transport
    • Made in the USA and rated for use up to 400°F

    Cons:

    • Disposable pans are not intended for reuse
    • 400°F temperature rating may not suit recipes that require hotter baking
    • Small individual size cannot replace a full-size pie pan

    Best for: Batch cooks, meal preppers, and hosts who need individual pot pie pans that can be served or transported without washing reusable dishes

    Not ideal for: Buyers seeking reusable bakeware, a larger family-size pie pan, or a vessel for recipes requiring temperatures above 400°F

    • Material:Tin
    • Quantity:12 pans
    • Capacity:14.6 fluid ounces
    • Top outside diameter:5 3/4 inches
    • Depth:1 13/16 inches
    • Maximum temperature:400°F
    • Care:Disposable; do not reuse
    • Origin:Made in Wheeling, Illinois, USA
    Our verdict

    “Choose this pack for convenient batch prep and cleanup-free serving, but opt for ceramic pans if you want reusable bakeware.”

    → See it on Amazon →

11. ONEMORE 6.8-Inch Ceramic Pie Pans, 16 oz, Set of 4

    

    Best for Individual Pot Pies

    View Latest Price

    For a chicken pot pie with room for a substantial filling and crust, these 6.8-inch ceramic dishes offer more space than the 5-inch Suwimut mini pans. Their 16-ounce capacity suits a hearty single serving, while ceramic retains heat during baking and at the table. The glazed surface is listed as nonstick, and the pans can go from freezer to oven or microwave, then into the dishwasher—useful for prepping portions ahead and keeping cleanup simple. The tradeoff is the four-pan set: it provides fewer portions than Suwimut’s eight-pan pack, and each dish takes more storage space. Choose these for individual pot pies rather than a batch of smaller tasting portions.

    Pros:

    • 16-ounce capacity accommodates a substantial individual pie
    • Ceramic construction retains heat for serving
    • Oven, microwave, freezer, and dishwasher safe
    • Nonstick glazed surface and lead- and cadmium-free glaze

    Cons:

    • Four pans yield fewer individual portions than the eight-pan Suwimut set
    • The 6.8-inch dishes take more storage space than smaller mini pans
    • Ceramic is less suited to buyers seeking lightweight disposable tins

    Best for: Home cooks making generous individual chicken pot pies who want reusable ceramic dishes that can move between freezer, oven, microwave, and dishwasher.

    Not ideal for: Cooks preparing many small servings at once or anyone short on cabinet space; the set has four relatively large dishes rather than eight compact pans.

    • Material:Ceramic
    • Quantity:4 pans
    • Capacity:16 ounces each
    • Diameter:6.8 inches
    • Maximum oven temperature:500°F (260°C)
    • Care:Dishwasher safe
    • Other listed uses:Freezer and microwave safe
    • Color:Red
    Our verdict

    “Choose this set for hearty, reusable single-serving pot pies; pick the Suwimut pans for more compact portions and a larger batch.”

    → See it on Amazon →

12. Suwimut 8-Pack 5-Inch Nonstick Mini Pie Pans

    

    Best for Batch-Making Mini Pies

    View Latest Price

    The Suwimut set is the batch-friendly choice here: eight carbon-steel pans let you prepare several individual pot pies at once, unlike the four larger ONEMORE ceramic dishes. At 5 inches across, each pan makes a smaller portion, so this format works well for lunch servings, varied fillings, or a gathering where guests can take their own pie. Carbon steel is designed to heat evenly, and the nonstick coating helps release the crust and simplify cleanup. The key limitation is the listed 175°C maximum oven temperature, which is lower than ONEMORE’s 500°F rating and may restrict recipes that call for hotter baking. These pans also lack the ceramic dishes’ stated freezer and microwave compatibility.

    Pros:

    • Eight pans support larger batches than the four-pan ONEMORE set
    • Carbon steel is designed for even heating
    • Nonstick coating helps with pie release and cleanup
    • Suitable for individual pies, quiches, tarts, and other small bakes

    Cons:

    • Five-inch size may be too small for a filling main-course portion
    • Listed maximum temperature of 175°C is lower than ONEMORE’s 500°F rating
    • Freezer and microwave safety are not listed

    Best for: Hosts and meal-preppers who want to bake several small, individual chicken pot pies in one batch.

    Not ideal for: Cooks who prefer generous portions or recipes requiring high oven temperatures; the pans are only 5 inches wide and list a 175°C maximum.

    • Material:Carbon steel
    • Quantity:8 pans
    • Diameter:5 inches
    • Dimensions:5 × 5 × 1.2 inches
    • Coating:Nonstick
    • Shape:Round
    • Maximum oven temperature:175°C
    • Care:Dishwasher safe
    • Color:Gold
    Our verdict

    “Pick Suwimut for numerous compact individual pies, but choose ONEMORE if you want larger portions and a higher listed oven-temperature limit.”

    → See it on Amazon →

How We Picked

I ranked these options by how well their format suits homemade chicken pot pie: portion size, expected cooking workflow, material, cleanup, and usefulness beyond a single recipe. I gave priority to tools that support familiar oven baking and reusable everyday cooking, while also recognizing that disposable tins or dedicated electric makers can be better fits for specific kitchens. Size and capacity matter because a pan that is too small may limit the filling, while a larger dish can make a more substantial individual serving.

The ranking reflects tradeoffs rather than treating every item as interchangeable. Aunt Shannon’s ceramic set leads as a flexible starting point; the disposable packs rank for batch use and convenience, and electric appliances are better for buyers who prefer a dedicated countertop workflow. I placed the empanada press in a specialized role because sealed hand pies are different from open-topped, dish-baked chicken pot pies. Product details supplied for this roundup do not establish cooking results or compatibility beyond the stated features, so buyers should verify care instructions, appliance dimensions, and recipe fit before purchase.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Chicken Pot Pie Makers

Choosing a chicken pot pie maker starts with deciding how you want to cook, serve, and clean up—not just picking a pan that looks the right size. These factors can help you avoid buying an appliance when a basic dish would do, or choosing a compact pan that cannot hold the portions you have in mind.

Choose an oven dish or a countertop appliance

An oven-safe pie pan fits into a cooking routine you may already have: prepare the filling, add pastry, and bake according to your recipe. A dedicated electric maker offers a separate appliance workflow, which can appeal to cooks who want a specialized tool but adds storage and counter-space demands. Before choosing an appliance, check whether its cooking format matches your preferred crust style and filling preparation; a maker designed for smaller pies may not behave like a standard pie dish. Avoid buying one based only on the word “pie” in its name, since pocket pies, quiches, and traditional pot pies have different shapes and assembly needs. If you want one tool for a broad range of oven recipes, a conventional pan is usually the more adaptable starting point.

Match pan diameter and depth to your serving

Diameter affects how much filling and crust each pie can hold, while depth affects how much filling can sit beneath the top crust. A small pan can be useful for individual servings, but a generous filling portion may leave too little room for pastry or lead to spills. Larger dishes take more oven space and may call for adjustments to baking time or recipe quantities. Deep foil pans can accommodate a roomier filling, though their disposable construction gives a different feel from a reusable ceramic dish. Think about whether you want a snack-sized pie, a full individual meal, or a dish to share, then compare both width and depth instead of relying on diameter alone.

Decide how much cleanup and reuse matter

Reusable ceramic and nonstick pans reduce the need to replace baking vessels after each use, but they still need washing and a place in the cupboard. Disposable aluminum tins are convenient for transporting pies, serving guests, or avoiding dishwashing, but repeated use is not their main purpose. Foil can also be less rigid than a sturdy reusable dish, so handling a filled pan may take extra care. A larger disposable pack makes sense when you bake for groups or share meals often; occasional bakers may prefer a small reusable set instead. Check the maker’s care directions before assuming a pan is dishwasher-safe or suitable for every oven setting.

Check the crust style before buying a press

A pot pie typically uses a baking dish to support filling and pastry, while an empanada-style press shapes and seals dough around filling. Those approaches produce different meals, even when both are described as pie makers. A press can help with shaping uniform hand pies, but it does not replace a baking dish for an open-topped, spoonable chicken pot pie. If your goal is a classic pot pie, confirm that the tool supports the shape and filling method in your recipe. For cooks who want portable, sealed portions, a press may be a useful specialty tool rather than an all-purpose pot pie solution.

Plan for batch size, storage, and transport

Set count is only useful when it matches how many pies you can bake at once and how many you need to serve. Several small pans may let you portion meals individually, but they can occupy more shelf space than a single larger dish. Electric appliances need a dedicated storage spot and may limit how many pies you cook in one round. Disposable pans are easy to pass along with food, while reusable ceramic dishes are better suited to keeping as part of your kitchen collection. Measure cupboard space and oven capacity, and decide whether pies will be eaten at home or carried elsewhere before settling on a set size.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I choose ceramic pans or an electric pie maker for chicken pot pie?

Choose ceramic pans if you want conventional oven baking, a reusable serving dish, and flexibility for recipes beyond pot pies. An electric pie maker is a more specialized choice for buyers who prefer a dedicated countertop appliance and are comfortable following its particular workflow. The two formats are not direct substitutes: appliance size and crust shaping can affect what kinds of pies are practical. Check the instructions for the specific model and compare them with your recipe before buying. If you are unsure, an oven pan is generally the simpler way to start.

Are 5-inch mini pans large enough for a full chicken pot pie serving?

They can suit a compact individual pie, but the actual serving depends on pan depth, filling quantity, and the amount of crust. A 5-inch pan may feel small if you want a generous meal-sized portion or plan to add a thick layer of filling. Larger 5.5- or 6.8-inch options provide more room, though they also use more oven and storage space. Check the stated depth as well as the diameter, since width alone does not show how much filling the dish can hold. If portion size matters, compare the pan dimensions with a dish you already use.

When are disposable aluminum pie tins a better choice than reusable pans?

Disposable tins make sense when you are baking for a group, sending food home with guests, or trying to reduce cleanup. The 60-pack is geared toward high-volume use, while the 12-pack of deeper pans may suit cooks who want fewer tins with more room for filling. Reusable ceramic or nonstick pans are a better fit for regular home baking when you want to keep the same dishes on hand. Thin foil pans can need careful handling when full, so consider how you will move them from oven to table. For frequent baking, compare the convenience of disposables against the storage and washing needs of reusable cookware.

Can an empanada press make a traditional chicken pot pie?

An empanada press is made to shape and seal dough around filling, so it is suited to a hand pie rather than a traditional open-topped pot pie baked in a dish. You may be able to use chicken pot pie filling in a sealed pastry, but the result has a different format and requires filling that works inside folded dough. It does not provide the same baking vessel as a ceramic or aluminum pie pan. Choose the press if portable sealed pies are your goal; choose a pan if you want the familiar dish-baked version. Check the press dimensions against your dough and intended filling before purchase.

What should I verify before ordering a ceramic or electric pie maker?

For ceramic pans, check the full dimensions, depth, care instructions, and any stated oven-use limits rather than assuming every ceramic dish handles every cooking condition. For an electric maker, check its countertop footprint, storage needs, power requirements, and the manufacturer’s directions for filling and crust preparation. In either case, think about whether the pieces fit your oven, cupboards, and usual batch size. Product names can suggest a use without spelling out every recipe or care detail. When a specification is missing, consult the manufacturer before relying on it for a particular cooking method.

Conclusion

For most cooks seeking a flexible starting point, I recommend Aunt Shannon’s Kitchen ceramic mini pans as best overall: they suit oven-baked individual pies without adding a dedicated appliance. Spare Essentials is my best value for batch baking and sharing, while Sunbeam is the best fit for buyers specifically seeking an electric pie maker. Beginners who want a straightforward oven setup can start with Aunt Shannon’s reusable set; cooks prioritizing a premium, reusable ceramic presentation can compare the larger ONEMORE 6.8-inch dishes with the other ceramic options. For specific needs, pick Durable Packaging’s deeper foil pans for disposable roomier portions, LOVECASA for six ceramic pans, or the Jumbo press for sealed hand pies rather than classic pot pie. Choose by cooking format and serving size first, then narrow the options by cleanup and storage.