The best frozen pizzas balance a satisfying crust and toppings with the right portion size for how you eat. I rank Poco Bero Margherita Neapolitan Pizza as the best overall for its classic, shareable style, while Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish is the standout for a filling, hearty meal and Against the Grain Gluten-Free Uncured Pepperoni is the clearest pick for gluten-free needs. The main tradeoffs are individual convenience versus a pizza meant to share, familiar flavors versus specialty styles, and variety versus buying a larger quantity of one kind. The lineup also includes small-format multipacks and options for specific cravings, so the right choice depends on more than toppings alone. Read on for the full breakdown and a guide to matching a frozen pizza to your table.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Key Takeaways
- Poco Bero Margherita takes the overall spot because its classic Neapolitan style offers a more distinctive alternative to the small, familiar-format multipacks.
- Lou Malnati’s Deep Dish leads for a hearty meal, but the multiple pack sizes and topping mixes suit different households; choose the variety pack for mixed preferences and the sausage-only pack for a narrower craving.
- Red Baron Singles Deep Dish and KITCH 24/7 Meat Lovers emphasize small portions and bulk quantity, making them more practical for individual servings than a pizza-night centerpiece.
- Against the Grain Gluten-Free Pepperoni is the lineup’s clearest dietary-specific choice; shoppers managing gluten should still check the package for current ingredient and handling details.
- Katie’s Wood-Fired Variety Pack and Fusion Mamma Buffalo Chicken offer more specialized flavors, while familiar pepperoni and supreme multipacks are easier bets for routine meals.
| Red Baron Singles Deep Dish Pizza Variety Pack, Pepperoni and Four Cheese, 12 Pizzas |  | Best for Quick Individual Meals | Quantity: 12 pizzas | Flavors: 6 pepperoni and 6 four cheese | Pizza weight: 5.6 oz each | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 4-Pack (2 Pepperoni, 2 Sausage) |  | Best Chicago-Style Deep Dish | Brand: Lou Malnati’s | Cuisine: Chicago-style | Pack size: 4 pizzas | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Poco Bero Margherita Neapolitan Frozen Pizza, 11 Inch, Pack of 6 |  | Best Neapolitan-Style Pick | Style: Neapolitan | Flavor: Margherita | Pizza size: 11 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| KITCH 24/7 7-Inch Meat Lovers Pizza, 8.3 oz, 24 per Case |  | Best for Foodservice and Bulk Portions | Brand: KITCH 24/7 | Diameter: 7 inches | Weight: 8.3 oz | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| DiGiorno Small Traditional Hand Tossed Crust Supreme Pizza, Pack of 10 |  | Best for Flexible Preparation | Brand: DiGiorno | Type: Frozen personal pizza | Crust style: Traditional hand tossed | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Gino’s East of Chicago Deep Dish Pizza 3-Pack (Crumbled Sausage) |  | Best for Hearty Deep-Dish Portions | Quantity: 3 pizzas | Diameter: 9 inches each | Total weight: 6 lbs | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Against the Grain Gluten-Free Uncured Pepperoni Pizza, 24 oz |  | Best Grain-Free Pick | Weight: 24 oz | Flavor: Uncured pepperoni | Crust: Three-cheese original crust | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 2-Pack (2 Sausage) |  | Best Premium Chicago-Style Pick | Type: Chicago deep-dish pizza | Flavor: Sausage | Quantity: 2 pizzas | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Fusion Mamma Buffalo Chicken Frozen Pizza, 12 Inch, Pack of 2 |  | Best for Buffalo Chicken Fans | Flavor: Buffalo chicken | Size: 12 inches | Pack size: 2 pizzas | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Red Baron Frozen Pepperoni Pizza, 6 oz (Pack of 12) |  | Best for Quick Individual Servings | Quantity: 12 pizzas | Weight per pizza: 6 oz | Total weight: 72 oz | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 6-Pack (3 Cheese, 3 Pepperoni) |  | Best for Chicago-Style Deep Dish | Brand: Lou Malnati’s | Pizza style: Chicago deep dish | Pack size: 6 pizzas | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Nutrisystem Margherita Frozen Pizza, 12 Count |  | Best for Portion-Controlled Meals | Product type: Frozen margherita pizza | Pack size: 12 count | Preparation: Ready in minutes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Katie’s Wood-Fired Artisan Frozen Pizza Variety Pack, 6 Pizzas |  | Best for Artisan Toppings and Wood-Fired Crust | Pack size: 6 pizzas | Dough: 48-hour naturally leavened | Cooking method: Fired in an 800-degree wood oven | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| frozen pizza | Preparation |
|---|---|
| Red Baron Singles Deep Dish Pi | Microwave or oven |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dis | Oven-ready; about 40 minutes |
| Poco Bero Margherita Neapolita | Cook from frozen for 8–10 minutes at 425°F |
| KITCH 24/7 7-Inch Meat Lovers | Ready to bake |
| DiGiorno Small Traditional Han | — |
| Gino’s East of Chicago Deep Di | — |
| Against the Grain Gluten-Free | — |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dis | — |
| Fusion Mamma Buffalo Chicken F | Bake from frozen |
| Red Baron Frozen Pepperoni Piz | Microwaveable |
| Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dis | — |
| Nutrisystem Margherita Frozen | Ready in minutes |
| Katie’s Wood-Fired Artisan Fro | Frozen; bake at home |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Red Baron Singles Deep Dish Pizza Variety Pack, Pepperoni and Four Cheese, 12 Pizzas
Individually wrapped portions and two familiar flavors make this variety pack an easy fit for households that want a quick personal pizza without thawing or dividing a larger pie. Each 5.6-ounce deep-dish pizza can be heated in the microwave or oven, giving it more prep flexibility than Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, which needs about 40 minutes in the oven. The tradeoff is a more convenience-focused format: these small pizzas are better suited to snacks or individual meals than a shared, restaurant-style dinner. The equal split of pepperoni and four cheese also offers choice without committing to one topping, though buyers seeking a distinctive, wood-fired crust should look to Poco Bero Margherita instead.
Pros:- Includes six pepperoni and six four-cheese pizzas
- Individually wrapped portions are convenient to store and serve
- Microwave or oven preparation allows flexibility
- Deep-dish format gives each personal pizza a substantial style
Cons:- Small 5.6-ounce portions may not satisfy bigger appetites on their own
- Requires freezer space for a 12-pizza pack
- Microwave convenience may not suit buyers prioritizing an oven-baked crust
Best for: Households that want individually portioned pizzas, familiar flavors, and the option to use a microwave for a fast meal.
Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking a large, shareable pizza or a specialty crust with a more distinctively artisanal style.
- Quantity:12 pizzas
- Flavors:6 pepperoni and 6 four cheese
- Pizza weight:5.6 oz each
- Style:Deep dish
- Preparation:Microwave or oven
- Packaging:Individually wrapped portions
Our verdict“Choose this pack for fast, portion-controlled meals with two classic flavors; skip it if you want a larger pizza to share.”
Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 4-Pack (2 Pepperoni, 2 Sausage)
Flaky buttery crust, Wisconsin mozzarella, and vine-ripened tomatoes set this four-pack apart for buyers who want a more substantial Chicago-style pie rather than a quick personal pizza. The pack has two pepperoni and two sausage pizzas, so it provides some variety while keeping the focus on classic toppings. Compared with the Red Baron Singles Deep Dish Variety Pack, these 9-inch pizzas are built for a fuller oven-baked meal, not a microwave-speed snack. That comes with a clear cost in time: heating takes about 40 minutes, making this a poor fit for last-minute hunger. I’d choose it over Poco Bero when a rich, hearty deep-dish format matters more than a lighter Neapolitan style.
Pros:- Four 9-inch pizzas provide a more substantial format than personal singles
- Includes two pepperoni and two sausage pizzas
- Wisconsin mozzarella and vine-ripened tomatoes define a classic deep-dish profile
- Oven-ready preparation requires no assembly
Cons:- About 40 minutes of heating makes it slow for an immediate meal
- Oven-only preparation offers less flexibility than Red Baron Singles
- Deep-dish style may feel too rich or heavy for buyers seeking a lighter pizza
Best for: Deep-dish fans planning a sit-down meal who want classic sausage and pepperoni options in 9-inch pies.
Not ideal for: People who need a fast weeknight snack, prefer microwave preparation, or want a lighter, thinner-crust pizza.
- Brand:Lou Malnati’s
- Cuisine:Chicago-style
- Pack size:4 pizzas
- Pizza size:9 inches
- Flavors:2 pepperoni and 2 sausage
- Crust:Flaky buttery crust
- Preparation:Oven-ready; about 40 minutes
Our verdict“Pick this four-pack for a planned, hearty Chicago-style meal, not when speed or a light crust is the priority.”
Poco Bero Margherita Neapolitan Frozen Pizza, 11 Inch, Pack of 6
Handmade in Naples, long-leavened dough, and wood-fired cooking give this 11-inch Margherita a different purpose from the heavier pies in this roundup. Its simple topping style makes the crust and traditional Neapolitan approach the main draw, while all-natural, non-GMO ingredients and sourcing from farms in Campania and southern Italy add detail for ingredient-minded buyers. It cooks from frozen in about 8–10 minutes at 425°F, far faster than the roughly 40 minutes needed for Lou Malnati’s Chicago deep dish. The tradeoff is less convenience at serving time: Poco Bero requires an oven and offers no microwave option, unlike Red Baron Singles. Its six-pizza pack also calls for freezer room and a preference for Margherita rather than varied toppings.
Pros:- Handmade in Naples using traditional Neapolitan methods
- Long-leavened dough and wood-fired cooking distinguish the crust style
- Cooks from frozen in about 8–10 minutes at 425°F
- Made with all-natural, non-GMO ingredients
Cons:- Requires oven preparation, unlike the microwave-ready Red Baron Singles
- Only the Margherita flavor is included
- Six pizzas require substantial freezer storage
Best for: Buyers who want an oven-baked Neapolitan-style Margherita, value traditional production details, and can store a six-pizza pack.
Not ideal for: Microwave-only households, shoppers wanting meat or varied topping choices, or anyone short on freezer space.
- Style:Neapolitan
- Flavor:Margherita
- Pizza size:11 inches
- Quantity:6 pizzas
- Preparation:Cook from frozen for 8–10 minutes at 425°F
- Ingredients:All-natural, non-GMO; primarily sourced from small farms in Campania and southern Italy
- Storage:Frozen; roughly 12-month shelf life
Our verdict“Choose Poco Bero for a relatively quick, oven-baked Neapolitan Margherita; pass if you need microwave convenience or topping variety.”
KITCH 24/7 7-Inch Meat Lovers Pizza, 8.3 oz, 24 per Case
Twenty-four ready-to-bake personal pizzas make this case the clearest fit for a break room, concession setup, or household that regularly serves individual meals. At 7 inches and 8.3 ounces, each pizza is larger by weight than a Red Baron single, while the meat-topped profile offers a heartier choice than Poco Bero’s Margherita. The appeal is straightforward portioning: there’s no need to cut a shared pie, and baking produces a hot individual serving. But the case quantity is also the main limitation. Compared with DiGiorno’s 10-pack, 24 pizzas demand more freezer capacity and may be excessive for a small household. The product data does not specify toppings beyond savory meat, tomato sauce, and cheese, so buyers wanting a precise topping mix should choose a more clearly described option.
Pros:- Case of 24 suits recurring foodservice or group demand
- 7-inch, 8.3-ounce portions work as individual meals or snacks
- Meat toppings, tomato sauce, and cheese create a heartier profile than Margherita
- Ready to bake for straightforward preparation
Cons:- Twenty-four pizzas may be excessive for individual buyers
- Requires baking and freezer storage
- Topping details are less specific than DiGiorno’s listed Supreme ingredients
Best for: Foodservice operators, shared workplaces, or large households that need a substantial stock of individual meat pizzas.
Not ideal for: Single buyers or small households with limited freezer space, or shoppers who need detailed topping ingredients before choosing.
- Brand:KITCH 24/7
- Diameter:7 inches
- Weight:8.3 oz
- Packaging:24 per case
- Type:Frozen personal pizza
- Toppings:Savory meat toppings, tomato sauce, and cheese
- Preparation:Ready to bake
Our verdict“Buy this case for dependable individual meat-pizza portions in a high-volume setting, not for a small freezer or occasional use.”
DiGiorno Small Traditional Hand Tossed Crust Supreme Pizza, Pack of 10
Oven, microwave, or air fryer preparation gives this 10-pack the broadest cooking flexibility among these picks, a practical advantage over Poco Bero’s oven-only method and Lou Malnati’s longer oven bake. Each personal pizza combines sausage, pepperoni, green and red peppers, and onions on a hand-tossed crust described as crisp outside and soft inside, with 14 grams of protein per serving. That makes it a more topping-forward option than Red Baron’s two-flavor singles, though the latter includes a four-cheese choice for those avoiding meat toppings. DiGiorno is built around convenience and individual servings, not a large shared pie or a single specialty style. Buyers should also account for the listed pepperoni blend of pork, chicken, and beef and keep the pack frozen until needed.
Pros:- Can be prepared in an oven, microwave, or air fryer
- Ten personal pizzas suit portioned meals and stocking up
- Supreme toppings include sausage, pepperoni, peppers, and onions
- Hand-tossed crust is described as crisp outside and soft inside
Cons:- Meat toppings and the pork, chicken, and beef pepperoni blend limit suitability for some diets
- Ten pizzas require freezer space
- Personal format is less suited to serving a group around one shared pie
Best for: Households wanting personal Supreme pizzas with several cooking methods, especially when oven access or prep time varies.
Not ideal for: People avoiding meat or the listed pepperoni blend, and diners looking for a large shared pizza or a specialty crust.
- Brand:DiGiorno
- Type:Frozen personal pizza
- Crust style:Traditional hand tossed
- Toppings:Sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, red peppers, and onions
- Quantity:10 pizzas
- Protein:14 g per serving
- Preparation methods:Oven, microwave, or air fryer
Our verdict“Choose DiGiorno for topping-rich personal pizzas and flexible cooking methods, but skip it if you avoid meat or want a shareable pie.”
Gino’s East of Chicago Deep Dish Pizza 3-Pack (Crumbled Sausage)
For buyers who want a substantial Chicago-style sausage pie, Gino’s East offers three 9-inch pizzas with a combined six pounds of food. Chunky tomato sauce, aged mozzarella, and crumbled sausage give each pie a layered, filling profile that sets it apart from the thinner Fusion Mamma Buffalo Chicken pizzas. The three-pizza pack also makes it easier to plan several meals than Lou Malnati’s two-pizza sausage pack, though the exact portion size per person will depend on appetites and sides. The tradeoff is time and storage: these arrive frozen and need oven baking, while the large total quantity can be awkward for a small freezer or household. I’d choose it for a deep-dish craving, not for a quick weeknight slice.
Pros:- Three 9-inch pies provide substantial total food
- Chicago deep-dish style pairs chunky tomato sauce with crumbled sausage
- Aged mozzarella adds a distinct cheese component
- Ships frozen on dry ice for home baking
Cons:- Requires oven baking rather than quick microwave preparation
- Six pounds of pizza may be excessive for a small household
- Sausage is the only listed flavor in this pack
Best for: Deep-dish fans feeding a few hearty eaters or planning multiple sausage-pizza meals
Not ideal for: Small households with limited freezer space or shoppers seeking a quick, thin-crust pizza
- Quantity:3 pizzas
- Diameter:9 inches each
- Total weight:6 lbs
- Flavor:Crumbled sausage
- Style:Chicago deep dish
- Toppings:Chunky tomato sauce and aged mozzarella
- Shipping state:Frozen on dry ice
Our verdict“Choose Gino’s East for generous, oven-baked sausage deep dish, but skip it if freezer space or quick preparation matters most.”
Against the Grain Gluten-Free Uncured Pepperoni Pizza, 24 oz
This is the clearest fit in the group for shoppers avoiding both gluten and grains: its three-cheese crust is paired with tomato sauce, mozzarella, and uncured pepperoni. The ingredient exclusions also extend to seed oils, gums, preservatives, soy, and nuts, giving label-conscious buyers a more specific option than Red Baron Frozen Pepperoni Pizza, which is described around convenience and real cheese rather than these dietary features. Preparation takes 19 minutes, so it is not as immediate as Red Baron’s microwaveable singles. That wait may be worthwhile for someone whose restrictions make ordinary frozen pizzas unsuitable, but the grain-free crust and dietary positioning narrow its audience. I’d pick it for its stated ingredient profile, not as a universal pepperoni choice.
Pros:- Gluten-free and grain-free
- Made without seed oils, gums, preservatives, soy, or nuts, as described
- Three-cheese crust offers a distinct alternative to standard dough
- Topped with mozzarella and uncured pepperoni
Cons:- Listed preparation time is 19 minutes
- Must be kept frozen
- Dietary and pepperoni focus may not suit shoppers wanting a conventional or meat-free pizza
Best for: Gluten-free and grain-free shoppers seeking a pepperoni pizza with specified ingredient exclusions
Not ideal for: Buyers who prioritize microwave speed, a conventional crust, or a pizza without pepperoni
- Weight:24 oz
- Flavor:Uncured pepperoni
- Crust:Three-cheese original crust
- Dietary features:Gluten-free and grain-free
- Ingredient exclusions:No seed oils, gums, preservatives, soy, or nuts
- Preparation time:19 minutes
- Storage:Frozen
Our verdict“Pick Against the Grain when its grain-free ingredient profile is the priority; choose Red Baron instead for microwave convenience.”
Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 2-Pack (2 Sausage)
Lou Malnati’s is the more focused choice for buyers who want its signature buttery, flaky deep-dish crust and a named Chicago origin. Wisconsin mozzarella and vine-ripened tomatoes distinguish its ingredient profile, while the two-sausage format is smaller than Gino’s East three-pizza, six-pound pack. That makes Lou Malnati’s a better match for a planned meal or a gift than for stocking up on several large pies. Its roughly 40-minute oven preparation calls for advance planning, despite the oven-ready format; it is not a fast substitute for the microwaveable Red Baron pizzas. Sausage is the only flavor listed here, so shoppers wanting variety should look elsewhere. I’d favor this pack for a deliberate deep-dish dinner where crust character matters more than speed or choice.
Pros:- Flaky, buttery crust gives the deep dish a distinctive texture
- Made with Wisconsin mozzarella and vine-ripened tomatoes
- Two oven-ready pizzas suit a planned meal or gift
- Chicago-style sausage format offers a focused alternative to thinner frozen pizzas
Cons:- About 40 minutes of oven preparation requires advance planning
- This pack is limited to sausage flavor
- Two pizzas provide less total quantity than Gino’s East’s three-pizza pack
Best for: Deep-dish enthusiasts planning a special meal or gift and seeking a buttery crust with sausage
Not ideal for: Shoppers needing a fast meal, multiple flavor options, or a large multi-pizza supply
- Type:Chicago deep-dish pizza
- Flavor:Sausage
- Quantity:2 pizzas
- Crust:Buttery and flaky
- Cheese:Wisconsin mozzarella
- Tomatoes:Hand-picked vine-ripened tomatoes
- Preparation time:About 40 minutes
- Origin:Chicago
Our verdict“Choose Lou Malnati’s for a planned, premium-leaning sausage deep-dish meal, not for speed or flavor variety.”
Fusion Mamma Buffalo Chicken Frozen Pizza, 12 Inch, Pack of 2
Fusion Mamma brings a different flavor direction to a lineup heavy on pepperoni and Chicago-style sausage: buffalo-style sauce, seasoned chicken, herbs, and real mozzarella on two 12-inch pizzas. The pair offers more conventional round-pizza versatility than the smaller, deep-dish Gino’s East pies, while its bake-from-frozen format avoids thawing or extra assembly. The main tradeoff is audience: the buffalo flavor is described as mildly spicy, which may not work for spice-sensitive eaters, and the product is made in a shared facility with several common allergens. That facility information matters for buyers managing allergy risks. Compared with the pepperoni-focused Against the Grain pizza, this is the better pick for chicken and buffalo-style flavor, but it does not offer the same stated gluten-free and grain-free positioning.
Pros:- Two 12-inch pizzas provide flexible portions for meals
- Can be baked directly from frozen
- Uses 100% real mozzarella cheese
- Buffalo-style sauce, seasoned chicken, and herbs add variety beyond classic pepperoni
Cons:- Mild spice may not suit every palate
- Made in a shared facility with milk, eggs, wheat, soy, peanuts, and nuts listed
- No preparation time or crust style is specified in the product details
Best for: Households that enjoy buffalo-style chicken toppings and want two standard-size pizzas ready to bake from frozen
Not ideal for: Spice-sensitive eaters or people who need to avoid allergens handled in the shared facility
- Flavor:Buffalo chicken
- Size:12 inches
- Pack size:2 pizzas
- Toppings:Seasoned chicken and herbs
- Cheese:100% real mozzarella
- Preparation:Bake from frozen
- Storage:Keep frozen
- Allergens:Milk, eggs, wheat, soybean, peanuts, and nuts listed for shared facility
Our verdict“Pick Fusion Mamma for an easy-to-bake buffalo chicken option, provided its spice and shared-facility allergen information fit your household.”
Red Baron Frozen Pepperoni Pizza, 6 oz (Pack of 12)
Red Baron’s strongest advantage is sheer convenience: 12 individual 6-ounce pizzas can be microwaved, making them a practical fit for quick lunches or separate servings. That sets this pack apart from the oven-baked Gino’s East and Lou Malnati’s deep-dish pizzas, which take more planning and are designed around larger pies. Red Baron also lists 100% real cheese and a deep, tender crust, but the product details do not specify cooking time or further topping and ingredient information. The small per-pizza size is useful when everyone wants an individual portion, though it is less suited to a shared dinner or a substantial deep-dish meal. I’d choose this for convenience and portioning, rather than for a more distinctive crust or elaborate topping profile.
Pros:- Microwaveable preparation offers a convenient alternative to oven-baked deep dish
- Pack of 12 supports multiple individual servings
- Each pizza weighs 6 ounces for clear portion sizing
- Made with 100% real cheese and a deep, tender crust
Cons:- Six-ounce pizzas are small compared with the 12-inch Fusion Mamma pizzas
- Product details do not specify microwave cooking time
- Flavor and ingredient information beyond pepperoni, cheese, and crust is limited
Best for: Busy households, students, or office kitchens that want individually portioned pepperoni pizzas for microwave preparation
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a large shared pizza, Chicago-style deep dish, or detailed dietary and ingredient information
- Quantity:12 pizzas
- Weight per pizza:6 oz
- Total weight:72 oz
- Flavor:Pepperoni
- Cheese:100% real cheese
- Crust:Deep, tender crust
- Preparation:Microwaveable
Our verdict“Choose Red Baron for quick, individually portioned pepperoni pizzas, not for a large or more distinctive frozen-pizza meal.”
Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 6-Pack (3 Cheese, 3 Pepperoni)
For buyers who want a hearty, pizzeria-style meal rather than a quick thin-crust dinner, this six-pack brings together three cheese and three pepperoni deep-dish pizzas. Its flaky butter crust, Wisconsin mozzarella, and vine-ripened tomato sauce give it a more substantial, layered character than the smaller, conventional Red Baron Frozen Pepperoni Pizza. The oven-ready format keeps preparation straightforward, though the roughly 40-minute bake takes longer than the minutes-ready Nutrisystem Margherita. That extra time suits a planned dinner or a gathering better than an on-demand snack. I’d choose it for its Chicago-style focus and balanced two-flavor mix, but buyers seeking broad topping variety or the shortest cook time should look elsewhere.
Pros:- Six pizzas split evenly between cheese and pepperoni
- Flaky butter crust gives the deep dish a distinctive, substantial base
- Wisconsin mozzarella and vine-ripened tomatoes are specified ingredients
- Oven-ready preparation suits planned meals and sharing
Cons:- Approximate 40-minute preparation is slower than quick-cooking options
- The pack offers only cheese and pepperoni
- Six pizzas require considerable freezer capacity
Best for: Households planning a filling Chicago-style dinner or a gathering where both cheese and pepperoni deep dish will be welcome.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who need a fast meal, want several topping choices, or lack freezer space for a six-pizza pack.
- Brand:Lou Malnati’s
- Pizza style:Chicago deep dish
- Pack size:6 pizzas
- Varieties:3 cheese, 3 pepperoni
- Crust:Flaky butter
- Cheese:Wisconsin mozzarella
- Sauce:Vine-ripened tomatoes
- Preparation time:Approximately 40 minutes
Our verdict“Choose this pack for a planned, filling Chicago-style meal, but pick Nutrisystem Margherita if speed matters more than deep-dish heft.”
Nutrisystem Margherita Frozen Pizza, 12 Count
This pack is aimed at a different kind of frozen-pizza dinner: 12 portion-controlled margherita meals designed for a weight loss plan. Individual portions make it easier to plan a single serving than with Lou Malnati’s six-pizza deep-dish pack, which is geared toward a fuller, more indulgent meal. The pizzas are described as ready in minutes and made with real ingredients, without artificial sweeteners or flavors. That makes this the more convenient pick for routine, quick dinners, though the supplied details don’t specify cooking method, nutrition figures, or the size of each portion. A California Proposition 65 warning for lead exposure is also listed, a meaningful drawback for shoppers weighing this option. I’d favor it for planned portions, not for feeding a group or seeking an elaborate pizzeria-style pie.
Pros:- Twelve portion-controlled pizzas support planned single servings
- Ready in minutes, according to the product description
- Made with real ingredients
- No artificial sweeteners or flavors
Cons:- A California Proposition 65 warning for lead exposure is listed
- The supplied product information gives no serving-size or nutrition figures
- Margherita is the only stated variety
Best for: People following a weight loss meal plan who want individual margherita pizzas for quick, portioned dinners.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a shareable family pizza, detailed nutrition information before buying, or a product without a listed Proposition 65 warning.
- Product type:Frozen margherita pizza
- Pack size:12 count
- Preparation:Ready in minutes
- Dietary positioning:Portion-controlled meals intended to support a weight loss plan
- Ingredients:Made with real ingredients
- Artificial sweeteners or flavors:None, according to product details
- Warning:California Proposition 65 warning for lead exposure
Our verdict“Pick this for quick, portioned margherita meals within a weight loss plan; choose Lou Malnati’s for a more substantial, shareable pizza dinner.”
Katie’s Wood-Fired Artisan Frozen Pizza Variety Pack, 6 Pizzas
Katie’s stands apart for buyers after an artisan-style pie rather than the sturdy, familiar heft of Lou Malnati’s Chicago deep dish. The listed 48-hour naturally leavened dough and 800-degree wood-oven firing point to an airy, wood-fired crust, while the featured pepperoni-and-honey combination pairs cup-and-char pepperoni with wildflower honey, stracciatella, and Fontina. Those toppings make this the more distinctive choice for diners who enjoy sweet-savory combinations; they may be less appealing to anyone who wants a straightforward cheese or pepperoni pizza. The six pizzas arrive frozen and need home baking, so this is not a ready-to-eat meal, and buyers need freezer room. Compared with Nutrisystem Margherita’s portion-focused convenience, Katie’s prioritizes specialty ingredients and pizzeria character over routine speed.
Pros:- 48-hour naturally leavened dough gives the crust an artisan-style distinction
- 800-degree wood-oven firing is a standout cooking method
- Featured toppings include cup-and-char pepperoni, wildflower honey, stracciatella, and Fontina
- Six frozen pizzas provide several home-baked meals
Cons:- Requires home baking rather than serving ready to eat
- Frozen delivery requires enough freezer storage
- Pepperoni and honey is a specialized flavor combination that may not suit traditional tastes
Best for: Pizza fans who want a specialty, restaurant-style pie with wood-fired crust and adventurous pepperoni-and-honey toppings.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prefer classic, simple toppings, need a meal ready in minutes, or have little freezer space.
- Pack size:6 pizzas
- Dough:48-hour naturally leavened
- Cooking method:Fired in an 800-degree wood oven
- Preparation:Frozen; bake at home
- Featured variety:Cup-and-char pepperoni and honey
- Featured cheeses:Stracciatella and Fontina
- Ingredients:All-natural
Our verdict“Choose Katie’s for wood-fired character and distinctive toppings, but go with Nutrisystem Margherita for a simpler, portion-focused meal ready in minutes.”
How We Picked
I ranked these pizzas by how clearly each option serves a distinct buyer need: an everyday meal, individual portions, a group gathering, a specialty flavor, or a dietary preference. I weighed the product’s stated style and format, topping appeal, pack quantity, and how easily a shopper can understand the role it fills. A large case can make sense for repeat eaters, but quantity alone does not make a pizza the best choice if the portions or flavor are a poor fit.
The order favors options with a strong, broadly useful identity, then moves toward more specialized formats and flavors. I also considered tradeoffs: deep dish is filling but less suited to someone wanting a light, quick slice; variety packs offer choice but may include flavors not everyone wants; and bulk cases require enough freezer space and repeat demand. The product list does not provide consistent nutrition, ingredient, or preparation details, so I avoid claims that cannot be established from the supplied product information.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Frozen Pizzas
The best match often comes down to who is eating, how much freezer room you have, and whether you want a familiar pizza or a particular style. I’d settle those practical questions before choosing by topping name alone.
Match the pizza format to the meal
Start by deciding whether the pizza is a snack, an individual meal, or the centerpiece of dinner. Small-format products such as singles and 7-inch pizzas are easier to portion, but may be less satisfying when several people expect a shared pizza-night meal. A larger specialty pizza can feel more like a centerpiece, though it may take longer to serve and may not suit varied appetites. Avoid comparing package counts without checking the number and size of pizzas inside; a bigger count does not automatically mean more food per person. If portions vary at your table, individual pizzas can reduce leftovers and let people choose separately. For a group, consider whether one flavor will please everyone or whether a mix is more useful.
Choose crust style for fullness and texture
Crust changes the eating experience as much as the toppings do. Deep dish tends to be a heartier, more filling choice, while hand-tossed, Neapolitan, and wood-fired styles signal different approaches to a thinner or more artisan-style pie. The product name alone cannot guarantee crispness or a specific texture after baking, since ovens and package directions vary. A common mistake is buying a thick, substantial pizza when the goal is a quick light meal—or picking a thinner style when diners expect a filling dinner. Check the package’s baking instructions and serving guidance before planning timing. If texture matters most, consider how your oven setup and available baking surface fit the directions.
Treat pack size as a storage decision
Multipacks and cases can simplify repeat meals, but they also commit freezer space and future meals to a particular product. A 24-count case makes more sense for a workplace, household, or routine that regularly uses individual pizzas than for a shopper who wants occasional variety. Smaller packs are easier to try without dedicating as much storage. Before buying, check whether each pizza is individually wrapped and how the package recommends storing it after opening; those details affect convenience. Do not assume a larger pack is better value if some of it may go unused. Match quantity to actual eating habits rather than the apparent convenience of having more on hand.
Decide whether variety or consistency matters more
A variety pack helps when people disagree about toppings, but it is only useful if the included options appeal to the group. A single-flavor pack gives a predictable choice for someone who already knows what they like and wants repeatable meals. Specialty flavors such as buffalo chicken can make pizza night feel less routine, yet they are a riskier choice for mixed company than pepperoni or cheese. Think about whether you are buying for one person or several, and whether leftovers will be welcome if a flavor misses. For a first purchase, a smaller assortment can limit commitment. For a reliable household staple, consistency may matter more than novelty.
Check dietary details on the current package
A product name can point shoppers toward a dietary fit, but it should not replace checking the current ingredient and allergen information. This matters especially for gluten-free needs, where formulation and handling statements are relevant to the person eating the pizza. Do not infer that a pizza meets a dietary requirement just because its toppings seem suitable or its style sounds simple. Read the full label, including preparation and cross-contact information where provided, and follow any guidance from a healthcare professional for serious sensitivities. Specialty options can narrow the search, but they may also limit crust or topping choices. Make the dietary requirement the first filter, then compare flavor and format among products that meet it.
Compare convenience with the cooking setup
Frozen pizza convenience depends on more than the time it takes to heat: oven capacity, baking temperature, and whether several pizzas can cook at once all matter. A household oven may handle one pizza comfortably but struggle to prepare multiple different products at the same time. Check each package’s directions rather than assuming all frozen pizzas use the same temperature or timing. If you are serving a group, cooking pizzas with different crust styles may complicate the schedule. Individual pizzas can help diners eat in shifts, while a shared pie can be simpler when everyone is ready together. Plan around the instructions and the oven you have, not an assumed universal bake time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which frozen pizza is the best choice for a filling dinner?
I’d start with one of the Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish options because the deep-dish format is designed for a heartier meal than the small individual pizzas in this lineup. Pick the pack size and toppings based on how many people will eat it and whether they prefer sausage, pepperoni, or cheese. A single deep-dish pizza may not suit diners who want a lighter meal or a thinner crust. Check the package’s serving guidance before deciding how many pizzas to prepare.
Are individual frozen pizzas a better buy for one person?
Individual formats such as Red Baron Singles and KITCH 24/7 Meat Lovers can be easier to portion than a larger pizza, especially when people eat at different times. They also make it simpler to offer different flavors without dividing one pie. The tradeoff is that a case or multipack can take up substantial freezer space and may be more than a single shopper needs. Compare the number of pizzas with the package’s stated size and your likely eating schedule before choosing.
How should I choose between a variety pack and one flavor?
Choose a variety pack when the pizzas will be shared by people with different topping preferences or when you want several options available. The Red Baron Singles Variety Pack mixes pepperoni and four cheese, while Lou Malnati’s six-pack combines cheese and pepperoni deep dish. A single-flavor pack is simpler if you already know what you enjoy and want a dependable repeat choice. Variety only helps if the included flavors will actually get eaten, so check the pack contents before buying.
What should I check when buying a frozen pizza for someone who avoids gluten?
Against the Grain Gluten-Free Uncured Pepperoni Pizza is the lineup’s most direct option for shoppers looking for a gluten-free product. The name is a useful starting point, not a substitute for reading the current package label. Check ingredients, allergen statements, and any handling information relevant to the person’s needs, especially when cross-contact is a concern. If the restriction is medically necessary, follow the person’s clinician’s advice about acceptable products.
When does a specialty frozen pizza make more sense than a familiar pepperoni pie?
A specialty pizza makes sense when you are intentionally looking for a different flavor or style rather than a dependable choice for a mixed group. Fusion Mamma Buffalo Chicken and Katie’s Wood-Fired Artisan Variety Pack offer more distinctive directions than standard pepperoni options. Those choices may be a better fit for a themed meal or diners who enjoy trying different flavors, but they can be less predictable for children or cautious eaters. If you are unsure how the group will respond, choose a familiar option for the main meal and reserve the specialty pizza for an extra choice.
Conclusion
For the broadest appeal among these options, I’d start with Poco Bero Margherita Neapolitan Pizza as my best overall pick; it offers a classic style without leaning on bulk or an especially narrow flavor. For best value by format, the Red Baron Singles Variety Pack suits households that want individual portions and two familiar toppings, while buyers should confirm pack size and freezer capacity. My best premium-style choice is Katie’s Wood-Fired Artisan Variety Pack for shoppers seeking a more distinctive pizza-night option. For beginners or cautious eaters, a familiar pepperoni or cheese option such as Red Baron Frozen Pepperoni or a cheese-and-pepperoni variety pack is an easier starting point than buffalo chicken or deep dish. For specific needs, choose Against the Grain for a gluten-free-focused option, Lou Malnati’s for a hearty Chicago-style meal, or KITCH 24/7 and Red Baron Singles for individual servings. Match the pizza to your appetite, storage space, and dietary requirements, then check the current package details before ordering.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
